Erica Nol

Introduction

I presented the Ontario Field Ornithologists’ (OFO) 2022 Distinguished Ornithologist Award (DOA) to Dr. Erica Nol at the Annual General Meeting of the OFO in Leamington on 24 September 2022. I have known Erica for over two decades, during which time I worked, volunteered and completed two graduate degrees under her supervision. I can safely claim that Erica is one of the most enthusiastic, dedicated and passionate ambassadors of wildlife conservation and sustainable living in Ontario and beyond. She has had an extremely productive career, with numerous important on-the-ground and scholarly contributions to bird conservation. These impressive accomplishments alone are worthy of the OFO’s DOA, but the contribution I believe distinguishes Erica the most is what she has done above and beyond these pursuits. In particular, I refer to the manner in which she has thoughtfully trained and mentored legions of highly-skilled students who have continued on to distinguished careers in bird conservation, mostly in Ontario. I also note the especially strong and unique role model she has portrayed to them (and me) in doing so. It was, therefore, a great pleasure for me to present OFO’s DOA to Erica.

In the beginning

Erica’s life path was especially dynamic early on. She was born in the Netherlands in the 1950s when the country was recovering from the Second World War. Like many other Dutch at the time, her parents immigrated to Canada. In the first few years, Erica’s father finished his medical residency at St. Joseph’s Health Centre in Toronto. Next, the family of five moved to St. Thomas briefly and then settled in Uxbridge, where Erica’s dad served as a general practitioner. Later, Erica’s father went into psychiatry and they moved to Michigan. As a result, she completed her BSc at the University of Michigan. While there, she worked in the university’s Museum of Zoology, where she met her husband Chris Risley, who had worked with the late David Hussell and Erica (or Ricky) Dunn. Chris had just graduated with his BSc, working in the museum as a Curatorial Assistant, and David and Ricky were just starting out in their careers at Long Point Bird Observatory (LPBO), now part of Birds Canada. Later, all three would come to play important roles in Erica’s professional path, as well as become long-time, dedicated OFO members. But Ann Arbor proved too urban for Erica’s liking, so she spent a year of her undergraduate degree studying at Humboldt State University in rural, picturesque Arcata, California.

Erica’s ornithological career was hatched during these diverse early years. A series of experiences during this period very likely fueled her keen interest in birds generally and the major groups of birds and their habitats that she and her students would later focus on in their research.

The hook is set: on to academia

With her passion for bird research strengthening, Erica followed her undergraduate degree with an MSc at the University of Guelph, Ontario, supervised by Ron Brooks. Her decision to do so was heavily influenced by Chris, Ricky and David, whose passion for bird research was infectious. Initially, her project was to be on grassland birds, but Erica’s growing interest in shorebirds, especially plovers, was too great, and she made a career-changing decision by switching to factors affecting the nest success of Killdeers on Long Point.

The next major turn in Erica’s professional path simply fell before her. She wanted to carry on with a PhD researching shorebirds, but she also wanted to be close to Long Point, Chris and the Hussells, who were increasingly important mentors. It just so happened that Chris’ parents had a house in coastal Virginia and Allan Baker and his students at the University of Toronto were studying American Oystercatchers (Haematopus palliatus) close by! One of these students happened to be none other than Mike Cadman, who most OFO members will be familiar with, given his role as coordinator for Ontario Breeding Bird Atlases 1 to 3. Erica completed her PhD studying the reproductive strategies of American Oystercatchers while living at the house and divided the rest of her time between Toronto and Long Point: a lucky and conveniently happy arrangement for everyone.

Another chance event sparked the next major turn in Erica’s path. She knew she wanted to obtain a postdoctoral fellowship, and she had applied to various positions, but none had inspired her. She happened to attend a talk by Jamie Smith from the University of British Columbia and was struck by his kind ways and the nature of his research and teaching. So, she completed her postdoc with him working on Song Sparrows (Melospiza melodia) and, of course, shorebirds. Erica’s thoughtful teaching and mentoring style was no doubt inspired in large part by Jamie. It was, therefore, an extreme pleasure for me to nominate Erica for the Society of Canadian Ornithologist’s (SCO) Jamie Smith Memorial Award for Mentoring, which she graciously received in 2011.

Between graduate degrees, Erica also did contract work for the Canadian Wildlife Service on gulls and terns nesting on the Leslie Street Spit at Toronto and on the distribution of foraging seabirds in the Bay of Fundy, New Brunswick. With a firm academic footing in hand and a growing portfolio of scientific publications, Erica was now in a good position to secure something more permanent.

Anchored in one place: productivity soars

Shortly after completing her postdoc, Erica obtained employment at Trent University in Peterborough, Ontario, where she has happily remained for decades as an Assistant, then as an Associate and, ultimately, as a Full Professor, along with multiple appointments as Biology Department Chair and Director of the Watershed Ecosystems Graduate Program, which later became the Environmental and Life Sciences Graduate Program. It is from this vantage point at Trent that she really dug in and began delivering her legacy of contributions to ornithology and bird conservation in Ontario and elsewhere.

Erica’s academic accomplishments are impressive. She has attracted nearly 3.5 million dollars in research grants and has published over 150 peer-reviewed publications. She has taught countless undergraduate students through courses such as Introductory Biology, Ecology, Ornithology (20+ years) and her popular Research Design and Data Analysis (30+ years). She has also taught numerous field courses including Ecology of the Kawarthas, in Ontario, Coastal Field Ornithology, in Virginia and the Ecology of the Galapagos Islands. She has mentored over 70 graduate students, sometimes over a dozen simultaneously. Over half of her graduate students have gone on to professional careers in wildlife science in Ontario, almost all of them in ornithology.

Notably, at least 12 have gone on to work for the Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry, five for Birds Canada at Long Point, three for Canadian Wildlife Service and Environment and Climate Change Canada, three for Ontario Conservation Authorities and three for environmental consultants in Ontario. The collective influence that these numerous, well-trained individuals have had on bird conservation in Ontario and beyond is remarkable.

I once asked Erica, “How many grad students have you got now?” She replied, “Oh, I’ve really cut back, I’m down to single digits.” I continued, “So how many is that?” In all seriousness and without a hint of irony, she looked me in the eye and said, “nine.” Nonetheless, Erica always seems to provide the support and mentorship that each of her many students requires by throwing simply herculean effort to the cause.

The majority of Erica’s and her students’ research has been on forest-breeding birds (24% of her peer-reviewed publications) and arctic-breeding shorebirds (47%). The rest of her and her students’ research (29%) has involved a diverse set of topics, such as factors influencing the reproductive success of threatened Bobolinks (Dolichonyx oryzivorus) breeding in hayfields, effects of hyperabundant arctic-breeding geese on sympatric species, drivers of habitat quality in at-risk swallows and monitoring and conservation of secretive marsh birds.

With a strong start in forest bird research, Erica and her students turned to other timely questions of interest. Much of this involved measuring the response of forest bird abundance, diversity and reproductive success to different silvicultural techniques. Some of the work focused on the influence of harvest on specific species. Erica and her students also measured the effects of logging on insects) and the cavity-nesting bird community. And they looked at habitat selection, the influence of roads and trails and incidental take of nests in harvested and unharvested conifer plantations. This large body of silvicultural research led to improved forestry regulations, numerous best management practices and more sustainable harvests.

While Erica’s forest bird research was blossoming she was also becoming a world authority on shorebirds. Soon after starting at Trent University, she initiated a long-term research program on the behavioural ecology of Semipalmated Plovers (Charadrius semipalmatus) breeding at Churchill, Manitoba. She also continued studying the ecology of American Oystercatchers breeding along the Atlantic coast of the US, which was the focus of her PhD research. Later, Erica’s shorebird research expanded to many other species and locations including Akimiski Island, Nunavut; Mackenzie River delta, Northwest Territories; state of Georgia; Cuba; Argentina and Venezuela. This large body of shorebird research later became critical for measuring the impacts of climate change on shorebirds and has been especially important for identifying where and when shorebirds are most vulnerable throughout the annual cycle: on the breeding grounds or at migratory staging or overwintering sites. The research has led to action groups (e.g., American Oystercatcher Working Group), conservation plans and on-the-ground efforts to protect key sites, all of which are vital for conserving populations of these species, some of which are rapidly declining.

There is ample additional evidence of Erica’s scholarly successes. She has served as a peer reviewer for over 35 different journals, often reviewing up to 20 articles per year. She has been a subject editor for Avian Conservation and Ecology and Ornithological Applications, formerly The Condor. She is or has been President of the SCO and the Waterbird Society, an elected Fellow and Councilor of the American Ornithological Society (AOS) and co-Chair of the AOS’s Ad Hoc Committee on English Bird Names.

Erica has also received numerous academic awards including: Trent University’s Merit Award for Research and/or Service (which she has received in nine different years: 1992–2021), SCO’s Doris Huestis Speirs Award for outstanding lifetime contributions in Canadian ornithology (2015), Trent University’s Distinguished Research Award for outstanding achievements in research and scholarship (2019) and AOS’s Loye and Alden Miller Research Award for lifetime achievement in ornithological research (2020).

Casting long and far: on-the-ground contributions

There is no doubt that Erica has had a very productive academic career, although this is only part of the full story. She has been involved in a number of initiatives that go above and beyond her academic pursuits. For instance, she has contributed to Trent University’s Annual United Way Campaign, Peterborough Sustainable Development Committee and the Large Woodlands Conservation Cooperative. She has been heavily involved with assisting Syrian and Afghan refugees to get comfortably settled in Peterborough. She has also led a banding program for Northern Saw-whet Owls (Aegolius acadicus) at Trent University’s James McLean Oliver Ecological Centre on Pigeon Lake north of Peterborough for 25 years. The program has captured and released ~2000 owls and has en­hanced the practical skills of over 100 young ornithologists, three of whom have used the dataset for their honours thesis and one of whom published their results in Ontario Birds (Henry et al. 2015). With so many contributions to worthy causes, it is hard to imagine how Erica could fit anything else into her busy schedule. Although you can rest assured that if she can fit more, she will.

The motherly role

With such a long list of her own professional accomplishments, you would think that Erica might be the most demanding supervisor of all in terms of what she expects from her students. In fact, she is one of the most thoughtful and understanding academic advisors anywhere.

She definitely expects her students to work hard and to show good progress, but she is also a strong advocate of a healthy work-life balance. She very much appreciates that there is much more to life than your thesis or getting a publication submitted. She also has a remarkable ability to provide unfailing confidence and encouragement despite the challenges. No issue is insurmountable. It seems students always leave Erica’s office feeling better about everything than when they entered. And it is not just help and advice with research that is open to discussion. Just about anything can be brought to the table. It is quite possible to go into Erica’s office and get questions answered about data analysis, for example, but also come out with advice on how to improve your relationship with your partner, for instance. In fact, I can honestly claim that I have discussed things with Erica that I have only ever discussed with my own mother. Erica is quite literally an all-purpose supervisor: a true friend and a student’s mother away from home, so-to-speak. I suspect that many of Erica’s students have had a much more positive experience in graduate school due to her thoughtful guidance and mentoring.

Leading by example

Erica’s thoughtful mentoring is only one of the ways by which she positively influences others. She also teaches by example, by doing what she advocates. During my time at Trent University, Erica was one of the few professors, for instance, who regularly and consistently rode the bus or her bike to school, or went out of her way to carpool, to reduce carbon and mitigate climate change. There were other professors who did this too, of course, but Erica got noticed the most due to her dedicated regularity, and because of this, many graduate and undergraduate students were inspired to copy her lead. She would also proudly display and discuss her worm composting unit in her lab, as a means of diverting waste from the garbage stream to save energy. One of Erica’s former graduate students, Anne Corkery (Corkery 2013, Corkery et al. 2019), sums up Erica’s leadership in this manner quite nicely: “One of the most inspiring things about Erica, is that the way she lives her life is truly reflective of what she teaches. She cares deeply about the people and the natural world around her and will openly discuss these matters with those she meets. I always stand to learn something new from her, and I can truly say that knowing Erica has played a significant role in shaping me into the person I am today.”

Concluding thoughts

Prior to Erica, OFO’s DOA had been granted 22 times to 23 recipients. Only three (13%) of the previous recipients have been women. Ricky Dunn was the first in 2010, who received the award along with her now late husband David Hussell, presented to them by none other than Erica herself. Then Jean Iron in 2016 and Margaret Bain in 2019. Erica is, therefore, the fourth woman to receive the award. I have had the great pleasure of knowing and/or being closely mentored by all four of these accomplished individuals, and I am quite pleased, as I am sure you will be too, that Erica now joins them along with the many other worthy recipients.

It should now be very clear that Erica has made outstanding and authoritative contributions to the scientific study of birds in Ontario and beyond, that she has been a resource to the Ontario birding community, and that her research on birds has resulted in much new ornithological knowledge. All of these major accomplishments are, of course, worthy of the award. As we have seen, however, it is what Erica has accomplished above and beyond these professional accomplishments that I believe distinguishes her the most. Especially the manner in which she has thoughtfully trained and mentored legions of highly-skilled students and the strong and unique role model she has portrayed to them in doing so. And even more impressive, Erica, along with her husband Chris, somehow found time during all of this to raise three wonderful daughters!

Congratulations, Erica, as recipient of OFO’s 2022 DOA, and thank you for going above and beyond with your many important and meaningful contributions to ornithology and bird conservation in Ontario and elsewhere.

Doug Tozer